Playing with BB Guns
To a certain extent, we all carry remnants of our past with us. Whether it be a physical scar or something not immediately visible, our past stays with us as we grow up. The BB gun fight in Sag Harbor was symbolic in many ways. For one, it serves as a coming-of-age marker, where Benji and his friends have to fend for themselves instead of sticking together. The remnant of the memory-- the BB stuck above Benji's eye-- acts as a constant reminder of that event and that summer.
Had they worn the goggles Benji suggested earlier, Benji would not have a BB stuck near his eye. Along with being beaten up by his dad in the same chapter, this section of the book explores the consequences of toxic masculinity in Benji's life. Benji learns the cost of risky behavior to maintain his reputation.
Additionally, Benji's friends refusing to let him go to the hospital because it would get them in trouble shows that they prioritize themselves over Benji's health. Even though we momentarily see the bond between Benji and Reggie reform, Benji realizes that he's on his own, and no one's looking out for him except himself. The act of Randy pumping the gun more than 2 times, despite having agreed in advance that they wouldn't, also shows that Randy does not care about the safety of others.
Even though it was just a game from his teenage years, the BB gun fight seems to have had lasting effects and larger implications. Benji is learning how to protect himself and respond to things that come his way. As he begins integrating himself within society, he asks himself "how do I defend myself?"-- not that he doesn't know how, but rather, he doesn't know in what way. This chapter serves as a reminder for Benji that he's on his own, and even if his problems only consist of BB fights and school bullies at the moment, he needs to learn how to protect himself later on.
The fight teaches Benji important lessons about looking out for himself and the cost of masculinity. Through rather unfortunate lessons, Benji explores the way he presents himself and how he controls his reputation.
You bring up some really great points! I really like how you analyzed the scene as Benji realizing he's alone and needs to look out for himself because it was something I never really thought of before. I always just thought of the BB in Benji's eye representing a reminder to Benji to not do stupid things with serious consequences in the future. Benji himself said that it was uncharacteristic of him to participate in the BB gun fight so I think it also reminds him to stick to who he is instead of trying to mimic and fit in with other people like his friends.
ReplyDeleteI always like the description of Benji holding the "toy" gun in his hand for the first time, surprised by its weight and heft, calling "its insides dense with cause and effect"--a nice defamiliarization of the hugely consequential machinery encased within the gun (making it not at all like a "toy"), but also a reminder of the far-reaching consequences (potentially) of pulling the trigger, an unpredictable chain of cause and effect that might even inform "Ben's" way of looking at the world even today.
ReplyDeleteI agree that a big theme throughout Sag Harbor, and presumably something that follows Benji long after, is this idea of how to protect oneself. So many of the things Benji does throughout the book is with that question in mind - he mentioned how when he was younger, protecting yourself was done physically through fights and brawls. During the summer we see, you protect yourself with words, scathing and witty insults. Benji and his friend group's entire dynamic is basically just centered around that, and almost nothing else at times. It actually kind of feels like they're "testing" their masks and protective measures on each other here in Sag, before they head out to the rest of the world once summer ends. Now is the time to hone themselves and be "reinvented" - come up with a new and better facade to present the rest of the world in hopes of staying safe.
ReplyDeleteThat scene did kind of show Benji's friends' priorities. Some passed the test and others didn't. I wonder if the guns had been real if they would have acted differently
ReplyDelete